Gael Turnbull, Oddingley and being incurably curious

Around three decades before I first stepped into Oddingley parish in 2008, a local GP named Gael Turnbull did the very same. And for some years afterwards he walked the twisting country roads, he took snap shots of the Netherwood barn and the cottages that clung to the fringes of Church Lane, and he delved deep into the story of the Oddingley murders.

At home, pages of notes flowed from his pen until notebook upon notebook piled up about him, all crammed with dates, tables, sketches, maps, blood lines. I cannot know for exactly how long his labours continued, but I do know that when he finished his inquiries he had completed a manuscript entitled A Dirty Job For Captain Evans.

I’ve a photograph of Gael Turnbull before me now. It shows a man with silver hair, broad glasses, a thin face and a mischievous smile. His story of the murders was never published, instead it was deposited along with his notes and letters into the archives of the Worcester Records Office in two bequests: one in the 1990s and another following his death in 2004.

But the murders were far from the only topic to catch his imagination. I subsequently learnt that he was a poet with an international reputation – well known to Burroughs and Ginsberg – and, in addition, ‘a translator, lyricist, prose-poem writer, kinetic sculptor, morris dancer and book maker. He was also a doctor and anaesthesiologist; conscientious and intuitive in his trade.’

You can hardly hope to read a more colourful biography of a man than that contained in Turnbull’s obituary, published in the Independent. I’ll quote just one paragraph from it, a paragraph that neatly portrays a life of energy and intellectual curiosity all displayed in the course of just a single day:

‘Gael Turnbull gave his final reading on a library roof in bright sunlight this May at Exeter’s tEXt festival. He had boarded the train loaded with kinetic sculpture and Zola’s La Bête humaine to read. In Devon in the next 24 hours he visited Exbourne Church to peruse its tithe map, drank in the Scottish poet Seán Rafferty’s pub and saw his old house, whittled a wooden dagger, checked my ill son’s temperature, recited “Sir Patrick Spens” by heart and found a cob wall full of doves. The next day, thronged by people, he read participatory kinetic poems, and left for St Ives.’

I discovered Turnbull’s files on the Oddingley case about two years ago as I was beginning the edits for Damn His Blood. It was one of those unexpected and exciting discoveries that belong particularly to historical research. Sifting the papers it was clear we had followed the same threads, reached many of the same conclusions and puzzled over many of the same ambiguities. In several places he surpassed me, and to him must go credit for tracing Richard Heming’s opaque ancestry to its source – something that I write about in a chapter entitled The Man in the Long Blue Coat.

As a non-fiction writer, you’re rarely on your own ground. In all but the most obscure, individualistic or recent cases you’re following paths that other writers have blazed, trying to make the story your own. This can, of course, result in rivalry but it can also give rise to a sense of fellowship, as there is among Dickensians who study Dickens or Henricans who explore the reign of King Henry VIII. And if there is to be a collective nouns for those who’ve studied the Oddingley case, then what better title that Oddingleyians?

So this post is intended to thank Gael Turnbull and to remind people of his work. I think it’s best to end with this quote from his friend, the British poet Roy Fisher, I can’t better it:

‘Of all my lost friends he is the least dead. The unique pace of his mind, sometimes troubled, always curious, seems still to be keeping us company somewhere just out of reach.’

Gael Turnbull (1928-2004) – Nicholas Johnson’s Independent Obituary, Guardian Obituary, Collected Works

(Gael Turnbull and friends outside Netherwood Farm, Oddingley, looking up at the murder plaque.)

Photos kindly supplied by Jill Turnbull.


  • Carrie McKnight says:

    It was lovely to read this tribute to Gael. I was fortunate enough to know him as he married into my family in his mid-life – married my mother – in fact! The quotes you have picked out reflect him so well and I found it interesting to read of the shared and competing territories involved in researching biographies. I think Gael would have enoyed the notion of being an Oddingleyian. Congratulations on the publication of the book. I have been enjoying its serialisation on R4.

    • Peter Moore says:

      Hi Carrie, I’m really happy to have got this little piece down about Gael. His life just sounds so vibrant from what I’ve read about him and he’d put so much time and thought into this Oddingley story that it’s good to be able to acknowledge him.

      Very glad you enjoyed the R4 broadcasts and thanks for writing here.

  • One keeps stumbling over yet another absorbing aspect of Gael’s life. In his later years Gael was a much-loved poet frequenting the streets and poetry events of Edinburgh. He had a quality of puckishness which was enlivening to others; and a deep humanity ….as well as a great facility with ideas and words.
    I’m not a blog-reader but this one is a delight.

  • tony baker says:

    Just to echo Carrie’s remark – much enjoyed the tribute to a man who brightened our lives for many years in a delightfully modest, generous and entertaining way. Few men were ever so brilliant while making so little fuss about it. You recognised his attention to others immediately; you had to look to recognise how remarkable and broad the attention was. It seemed too natural for you to wonder about it.

    I don’t usually write notes on blogs, but I did want to say that it was a good way to start the day, reading this one. And to add that Roy’s comment at the end speaks for many. My son, who probably became aware of Gael around the age of 10, still talks about him as a man who walks with him from his childhood. One stroll they took together by the Loire stirred my son into writing a story before he could spell half the English words he used in it. I find myself often talking to him too, hearing his particular intonation and profoundly common sense of things. I suppose he isn’t there at such times but it’s hard to know. I wouldn’t be sure how you could check it out.

    • Peter Moore says:

      Thank you Christine and Tony for these comments – A quality of ‘puckishness’ seems a perfect description: enlivening for people he knew well, for people he met briefly, and even for me – who only met him through his notes and writings.

      I suppose the remarkable fact is that he retains this strong intellectual presence even now (I hear that the latest version of one of his poems is to be carved into the handrail of a bridge over a burn in the Cairngorms ), and this lasting influence has to be a testament to the vibrancy of his mind and the strength of his spirit.

      This all leaves me feeling that I would very much have liked to have shared a drink with him. Thanks again for writing.

  • Jill Turnbull says:

    Dear Peter, I’ve only just discovered the comments from my daughter and good friends Christine and Tony – just shows I should check these things more often. I have a copy of your Weather book and have enjoyed reading it – but am a long way from finishing it because I’ve been working on the final stages of a book of my own and have read very little of anything else recently. I look forward to finishing your book soon though – it’s a fascinating subject. What are you working on now? Do let me know if you are ever up in Edinburgh. Jill

Anything to say? Leave a comment: